| (03) 9269 0120Melbourne | 1800 677 402Rural areas | Locate us |
Victoria Legal Aid’s (VLA) procedures for reporting disclosures of improper conduct or detrimental action by Victoria Legal Aid or its employees.
1. Statement of support for whistleblowers
2. Purpose of these procedures
3. Objects of the Act
4. Definitions of key terms
5. The reporting system
6. Roles and responsibilities
7. Confidentiality
8. Collating and publishing statistics
9. Receiving and assessing disclosures
10. Investigations
11. Action taken after an investigation
12. Managing the welfare of the whistleblower
13. Management of the person against whom a disclosure has been made
14. Criminal offences
15. Review
Victoria Legal Aid is committed to the aims and objectives of the Whistleblowers Protection Act 2001 (the Act). It does not tolerate improper conduct by its employees, officers or members, nor the taking of reprisals against those who come forward to disclose such conduct. Victoria Legal Aid recognises the value of transparency and accountability in its administrative and management practices, and supports the making of disclosures that reveal corrupt conduct, conduct involving a substantial mismanagement of public resources, or conduct involving a substantial risk to public health and safety or the environment. Victoria Legal Aid will take all reasonable steps to protect people who make such disclosures from any detrimental action in reprisal for making the disclosure. It will also take afford natural justice to the person who is the subject of the disclosure.
These procedures establish a system for reporting disclosures of improper conduct or detrimental action by Victoria Legal Aid or its employees. The system enables such disclosures to be made to the protected disclosure coordinator or to one of the nominated Protected disclosure officers. Disclosures may be made by employees or by members of the public.
These procedures are designed to complement normal communication channels between supervisors and employees. Employees are encouraged to continue to raise appropriate matters at any time with their supervisors. As an alternative, employees may make a disclosure of improper conduct or detrimental action under the Act in accordance with these procedures.
The Whistleblowers Protection Act 2001 commences operation on 1 January 2002. The purpose of the Act is to encourage and facilitate the making of disclosures of improper conduct by public officers and public bodies. The Act provides protection to whistleblowers who make disclosures in accordance with the Act, and establishes a system for the matters disclosed to be investigated and rectifying action to be taken.
Three key concepts in the reporting system are improper conduct, corrupt conduct and detrimental action. Definitions of these terms are set out below.
A disclosure may be made about improper conduct by a public body or public official. Improper conduct means conduct that is corrupt, a substantial mismanagement of public resources, or conduct involving substantial risk to public health or safety or to the environment. The conduct must be serious enough to constitute, if proved, a criminal offence or reasonable grounds for dismissal. Examples:
Corrupt conduct means:
Examples:
The Act makes it an offence for a person to take detrimental action against a person in reprisal for a protected disclosure. Detrimental action includes:
Examples
Disclosures of improper conduct or detrimental action by Victoria Legal Aid or its employees, may be made to the following officers:
The protected disclosure coordinator
Mr Peter Tanner
Manager Internal Audit
350 Queen Street
Melbourne 3000
Phone: (03) 9269 0176
The protected disclosure officer
Ms Marie Drinkwater
Internal Auditor
350 Queen Street
Melbourne 3000
Phone: (03) 9269 0427
All correspondence, phone calls and e-mails from internal or external whistleblowers will be referred to the protected disclosure coordinator. Where a person is contemplating making a disclosure and is concerned about approaching the protected disclosure coordinator or a protected disclosure officer in the workplace, he or she can call the relevant officer and request a meeting in a discreet location away from the workplace.
A disclosure about improper conduct or detrimental action by Victoria Legal Aid or its employees, may also be made directly to the Ombudsman:
The Ombudsman
Victoria Level 22, 459 Collins Street
Melbourne Victoria 3000 (DX 210174)
Website: http://www.ombudsman.vic.gov.au/
Email: ombudvic@ombudsman.vic.gov.au
Tel: (03) 9613 6222
Toll free: 1800 806 314
Ombudsman Tel: (03) 9613 6202
The following table sets out where disclosures about persons other than employees of Victoria Legal Aid should be made.
| Person who is the subject of the disclosure | Person/body to whom the disclosure must be made |
|---|---|
| Employee of a public body | That public body or the Ombudsman |
| Member of Parliament (Legislative Assembly) | Speaker of the Legislative Assembly |
| Member of Parliament (Legislative Council) | President of the Legislative Council |
| Councillor | The Ombudsman |
| Chief Commissioner of Police | The Ombudsman or Deputy Ombudsman |
| Member of the police force | The Ombudsman, Deputy Ombudsman or Chief Commissioner of Police |
Employees are encouraged to report known or suspected incidences of improper conduct or detrimental action in accordance with these procedures. All employees of Victoria Legal Aid have an important role to play in supporting those who have made a legitimate disclosure. They must refrain from any activity that is, or could be perceived to be, victimisation or harassment of a person who makes a disclosure. Furthermore, they should protect and maintain the confidentiality of a person they know or suspect to have made a disclosure.
Protected disclosure officers will:
The protected disclosure coordinator has a central ‘clearinghouse’ role in the internal reporting system. He or she will:
The investigator will be responsible for carrying out an internal investigation into a disclosure where the Ombudsman has referred a matter to the public body. An investigator may be a person from within an organisation or a consultant engaged for that purpose.
The welfare manager is responsible for looking after the general welfare of the whistleblower. The welfare manager will:
Victoria Legal Aid will take all reasonable steps to protect the identity of the whistleblower. Maintaining confidentiality is crucial in ensuring reprisals are not made against a whistleblower. The Act requires any person who receives information due to the handling or investigation of a protected disclosure, not to disclose that information except in certain limited circumstances. Disclosure of information in breach of section 22 constitutes an offence that is punishable by a maximum fine of 60 penalty units ($6000) or six months imprisonment or both. The circumstances in which a person may disclose information obtained about a protected disclosure include:
However, the Act prohibits the inclusion of particulars in any report or recommendation that is likely to lead to the identification of the whistleblower. The Act also prohibits the identification of the person who is the subject of the disclosure in any particulars included in an annual report. Victoria Legal Aid will ensure all files, whether paper or electronic, are kept in a secure room and can only be accessed by the protected disclosure coordinator, protected disclosure officer, the investigator or welfare manager (in relation to welfare matters).
All printed material will be kept in files that are clearly marked as a Whistleblower Protection Act matter, and warn of the criminal penalties that apply to any unauthorised divulging information concerning a protected disclosure. All electronic files will be produced and stored on a stand-alone computer and be given password protection. Backup files will be kept on floppy disc. All materials relevant to an investigation, such as tapes from interviews, will also be stored securely with the whistleblower files. Victoria Legal Aid will not email documents relevant to a whistleblower matter and will ensure all phone calls and meetings are conducted in private.
The protected disclosure coordinator will establish a secure register to record the information required to be published in the annual report, and to generally keep account of the status of whistleblower disclosures. The register will be confidential and will not record any information that may identify the whistleblower. The register will contain the following information:
Where a disclosure has been received by the protected disclosure officer or by the protected disclosure coordinator, he or she will assess whether the disclosure has been made in accordance with Part 2 of the Act and is, therefore, a protected disclosure.
For the disclosure to be responded to by Victoria Legal Aid, it must concern an employee, member or officer of Victoria Legal Aid. If the disclosure concerns an employee, officer or member of another public body, the person who has made the disclosure must be advised of the correct person or body to whom the disclosure should be directed. (See the table above). If the disclosure has been made anonymously, it should be referred to the Ombudsman.
To be a protected disclosure, a disclosure must satisfy the following criteria:
Where a disclosure is assessed to be a protected disclosure, it is referred to the protected disclosure coordinator. The protected disclosure coordinator will determine whether the disclosure is a public interest disclosure.
Where a disclosure is assessed not to be a protected disclosure, the matter does not need to be dealt with under the Act. The protected disclosure officer will decide how the matter should be responded to in consultation with the protected disclosure coordinator.
Where the protected disclosure officer or coordinator has received a disclosure that has been assessed to be a protected disclosure, the protected disclosure coordinator will determine whether the disclosure amounts to a public interest disclosure. This assessment will be made within 45 days of the receipt of the disclosure. In reaching a conclusion as to whether a protected disclosure is a public interest disclosure, the protected disclosure coordinator will consider whether the disclosure shows, or tends to show, that the public officer to whom the disclosure relates:
Where the protected disclosure co-ordinator concludes that the disclosure amounts to a public interest disclosure, he or she will:
Where the protected disclosure coordinator concludes that the disclosure is not a public interest disclosure, he or she will:
In either case, the protected disclosure coordinator will make the notification and the referral within 14 days of the conclusion being reached by the public body. Notification to the whistleblower is not necessary where the disclosure has been made anonymously. Public bodies like Victoria Legal Aid can receive a range of complaints from staff and members of the public. Only some of these matters will qualify for protection and investigation under the Act. The task for Victoria Legal Aid is to ensure the appropriate policy and procedure are applied to the particular circumstances of each case. The following table has been prepared to provide assistance when dealing with complaints and disclosures. Corrupt conduct, substantial mismanagement of public resources, conduct involving substantial risk to public safety or health or the environment, or detrimental action taken in reprisal for the making of a disclosure about the above matters.
Where the Ombudsman refers a protected disclosure to Victoria Legal Aid for investigation, the protected disclosure coordinator will appoint an investigator to carry out the investigation. The objectives of an investigation will be:
Before commencing an investigation, the protected disclosure coordinator will draw up terms of reference and obtain authorisation for those terms by the chief executive officer. The terms of reference will set a date by which the investigation report is to be concluded, and will describe the resources available to the investigator to complete the investigation within the time set. The protected disclosure coordinator may approve, if reasonable, an extension of time requested by the investigator. The terms of reference will require the investigator to make regular reports to the protected disclosure coordinator who, in turn, is to keep the Ombudsman informed of general progress.
The investigator will prepare an investigation plan for approval by the protected disclosure coordinator. The plan will list the issues to be substantiated and describe the avenue of inquiry. It will address the following issues:
At the commencement of the investigation, the whistleblower should be:
The investigator will be sensitive to the whistleblower’s possible fear of reprisals and will be aware of the statutory protection’s provided to the whistleblower.
The principles of natural justice will be followed in any investigation of a public interest disclosure. The principles of natural justice concern procedural fairness and ensure a fair decision is reached by an objective decision maker. Maintaining procedural fairness protects the rights of individuals and enhances public confidence in the process.
Victoria Legal Aid will have regard to the following issues in ensuring procedural fairness:
The investigator will make contemporaneous notes of all discussions and phone calls, and all interviews with witnesses will be taped. All information gathered in an investigation will be stored securely.
Interviews will be conducted in private and the investigator will take all reasonable steps to protect the identity of the whistleblower. Where disclosure of the identity of the whistleblower cannot be avoided, due to the nature of the allegations, the investigator will warn the whistleblower and his or her welfare manager of this probability. It is in the discretion of the investigator to allow any witness to have legal or other representation or support during an interview. If a witness has a special need for legal representation or support, permission should be granted.
The protected disclosure coordinator will make a decision regarding the referral of an investigation to the Ombudsman where, on the advice of the investigator:
The protected disclosure coordinator will ensure the whistleblower is kept regularly informed concerning the handling of a protected disclosure and an investigation. The protected disclosure coordinator will report to the Ombudsman about the progress of an investigation. Where the Ombudsman or the whistleblower requests information about the progress of an investigation, that information will be provided within 28 days of the date of the request.
At the conclusion of the investigation, the investigator will submit a written report of his or her findings to the protected disclosure coordinator. The report will contain:
Where the investigator has found that the conduct disclosed by the whistleblower has occurred, recommendations made by the investigator will include:
The report will be accompanied by:
Where the investigator’s report is to include an adverse comment against any person, that person will be given the opportunity to respond and his or her defence will be fairly included in the report. The report will not disclose particulars likely to lead to the identification of the whistleblower.
If the protected disclosure coordinator is satisfied that the investigation has found that the disclosed conduct has occurred, he or she will recommend to the chief executive officer the action that must be taken to prevent the conduct from continuing or occurring in the future. The protected disclosure coordinator may also recommend that action be taken to remedy any harm or loss arising from the conduct. The protected disclosure coordinator will provide a written report to Attorney General (Victorian), the Ombudsman and the whistleblower setting out the findings of the investigation and any remedial steps taken. Where the investigation concludes that the disclosed conduct did not occur, the protected disclosure coordinator will report these findings to the Ombudsman and to the whistleblower.
Victoria Legal Aid is committed to the protection of genuine whistleblowers against detrimental action taken in reprisal for the making of protected disclosures. The protected disclosure coordinator is responsible for ensuring whistleblowers are protected from direct and indirect detrimental action, and that the culture of the workplace is supportive of protected disclosures being made. The protected disclosure coordinator will appoint a welfare manager to all whistleblowers who have made a protected disclosure. The welfare manager will:
All employees will be advised that it is an offence for a person to take detrimental action in reprisal for a protected disclosure. The maximum penalty is a fine of 240 penalty units ($24,000) or two years imprisonment or both. The taking of detrimental action in breach of this provision can also be grounds for making a disclosure under the Act and can result in an investigation. Detrimental action includes:
The protected disclosure coordinator will ensure the whistleblower is kept informed of action taken in relation to his or her disclosure, and the time frames that apply. The whistleblower will be informed of the objectives of an investigation, the findings of an investigation, and the steps taken by Victoria Legal Aid to address any improper conduct that has been found to have occurred. The whistleblower will be given reasons for decisions made by Victoria Legal Aid in relation to a protected disclosure. All communication with the whistleblower will be in plain English.
If a whistleblower reports an incident of harassment, discrimination or adverse treatment that would amount to detrimental action taken in reprisal for the making of the disclosure, the welfare manager will:
The taking of detrimental action in reprisal for the making of a disclosure can be an offence against the Act as well as grounds for making a further disclosure. Where such detrimental action is reported, the protected disclosure coordinator will assess the report as a new disclosure under the Act. Where the protected disclosure coordinator is satisfied that the disclosure is a public interest disclosure, he or she will refer it to the Ombudsman. If the Ombudsman subsequently determines the matter to be a public interest disclosure, the Ombudsman may investigate the matter or refer it to another body for investigation as outlined in the Act.
Where a person who makes a disclosure is implicated in misconduct, Victoria Legal Aid will handle the disclosure and protect the whistleblower from reprisals in accordance with the Act, the Ombudsman’s guidelines and these procedures. Victoria Legal Aid acknowledges that the act of whistleblowing should not shield whistleblowers from the reasonable consequences flowing from any involvement in improper conduct. Section 17 of the Act specifically provides that a person’s liability for his or her own conduct is not affected by the person’s disclosure of that conduct under the Act. However, in some circumstances, an admission may be a mitigating factor when considering disciplinary or other action.
The chief executive officer will make the final decision on the advice of the protected disclosure coordinator as to whether disciplinary or other action will be taken against a whistleblower. Where disciplinary or other action relates to conduct that is the subject of the whistleblower’s disclosure, the disciplinary or other action will only be taken after the disclosed matter has been appropriately dealt with. In all cases where disciplinary or other action is being contemplated, the chief executive officer must be satisfied that it has been clearly demonstrated that:
The protected disclosure coordinator will thoroughly document the process including recording the reasons why the disciplinary or other action is being taken, and the reasons why the action is not in retribution for the making of the disclosure. The protected disclosure coordinator will clearly advise the whistleblower of the proposed action to be taken, and of any mitigating factors that have been taken into account.
Victoria Legal Aid recognises that employees against whom disclosures are made must also be supported during the handling and investigation of disclosures. Victoria Legal Aid will take all reasonable steps to ensure the confidentiality of the person who is the subject of the disclosure during the assessment and investigation process. Where investigations do not substantiate disclosures, the fact that the investigation has been carried out, the results of the investigation, and the identity of the person who is the subject of the disclosure will remain confidential. The protected disclosure coordinator will ensure the person who is the subject of any disclosure investigated by or on behalf of a public body is:
Where the allegations in a disclosure have been investigated, and the person who is the subject of the disclosure is aware of the allegations or the fact of the investigation, the protected disclosure coordinator will formally advise the person who is the subject of the disclosure of the outcome of the investigation. Victoria Legal Aid will give its full support to a person who is the subject of a disclosure where the allegations contained in a disclosure are clearly wrong or unsubstantiated. If the matter has been publicly disclosed, the chief executive officer of Victoria Legal Aid will consider any request by that person to issue a statement of support setting out that the allegations were clearly wrong or unsubstantiated.
Victoria Legal Aid will ensure officers appointed to handle protected disclosures and all other employees are aware of the following offences created by the Act:
These procedures will be reviewed annually to ensure they meet the objectives of the Act and accord with the Ombudsman’s guidelines.